I'd skip the pillow.
A reasonably priced rappy plush thou... I'd have to give that one some thoughts.
Now the question is which rappy would you be more likely to shell out for? Not gonna lie, I love me some Rag Rappy and Nav Rappy. The derpyness way outdoes the kinda chibi look of the "Rappy". Kinda doubt I'm on the winning side of this argument though.
Never seen Rag Rappy, but I also like the Nav Rappy. It's a decently balanced amount of cuteness.